Dealing with Amendment One Rhetoric: Affirming Faith Forum was held Friday evening, February 24 at the LGBT Center of Raleigh to support LGBTQ folk and allies to discuss how to better address the negative messaging we are hearing in support of the constitutional amendment. As an ordained minister who is queer, I believe our work in affirming our faith, understanding our personhood, is about recognizing in ourselves and each other human dignity and the right of self determination. Now, as our access to human rights is being publicly debated as regards to the amendment, we need affirmation and strength to stand firm for justice and equality.
The forum was designed to provide a safe place to name the grievances that we as individuals have experienced due to anti-LGBTQ biases in the community, debrief from the harm of encountering verbal and even physical attacks, and provide camaraderie for each other. When one is under attack, especially in an identify-based conflict, without good options the only choice may seem to be to withdraw or ‘ignore’ the situation. Telling and listening to our personal stories from these experiences help with strategizing to establish more effective options for countering the attacks, be they stories of outrage, fear and/or courage.
I organized the agenda for the meeting and facilitated the meeting along with Jim Manchester. Participants were asked to share their stories, talking not only about the facts but more the feelings of frustration, anger, betrayal, loss, and futility. Participants reported having been threatened with verbal and physical violence, exposed to picketers at community events, and anxious about losing support from family members and communities that were their sole source of support.
Tracy Hollister, a LGBTQ community leader, spoke about her response to a heckler with love and humor, countering their bigotry with sparring and wit when she said to the disrupting gentleman, “Do you like women?” “I sure do,” he said, to which she replied, “So do I.” Jimmy Creech, a local author, co-founder of Faith in America, and a well known community ally, spoke about his countering someone’s anger with respect. “That is disarming when someone is hostile. To respond with respect.”
The stories that were told and the honest reactions shared by the participants varied from individual to individual. The value of the forum was about having a safe place and an empathizing presence to continue healing from past hurts and to think ahead about options, refining past choices and/or considering new ones. While there is a temptation to give another the ‘right answer,’ let’s face it, this is not a one size fits all situation. The forum provided an opportunity to share a common struggle for peace and fairness, assuage the wounds words of hate leave on one’s human dignity, and to try on new responses rather than a general session on “how to.”
Participants in the affirming discussion on February 24th included a straight Muslim woman, an atheist, several recovering Methodists and Baptists, and others.
The Affirming Faith Forum meets every fourth Friday at 6:30 at the LGBT Center.
Jenna Zirbel, Reverend
Ministry of Love and Justice
Rainbow Community Cares, Inc (rccares.org)
CWAC Movement, Inc (cwac.us)